A blog of the Philadelphia Bar Association’s Criminal Justice Section


The General Assembly has completed its term.  The term of the present General Assembly expires on November 30.  The new General Assembly will be sworn in on January 1.


Six Pennsylvania judges filed a lawsuit Wednesday in Harrisburg claiming that a provision of the Pennsylvania Constitution, which mandates all Pennsylvania justices and judges retire at the end of the calendar year in which they turn 70, violates their rights under the Equal Protection and Due Process clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution and under Article I of the Pennsylvania Constitution.

The lawsuit, filed by Robert C. Heim of Dechert LLP in the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania on behalf of Judge John Driscoll, Judge John W. Herron, Senior Judge Benjamin Lerner, Judge Sandra Mazer Moss, Judge Joseph D. O’Keefe and Judge Leonard N. Zito, names as defendants Governor Thomas W. Corbett Jr., Secretary of Pennsylvania Carol T. Aichele, Treasurer of Pennsylvania Robert M. McCord and Court Administrator Zygmont A. Pines.

“Some of our finest and most experienced legal minds are being denied unfairly the opportunity to serve the people of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, solely because of their age,” said Heim, who is serving as pro bono counsel for the judges.  “In today’s world, there is no good reason to think that judges who are 70 are not equally competent as judges who are younger.”

The suit notes, among other things, that:

— These judges have been singled out by the Pennsylvania Constitution on the basis of age – not ability – and are treated differently than other officers and employees of the Commonwealth, who are not forced to retire due to age.

— To the extent the mandatory retirement provision is an attempt to prevent incapacitated judges from causing harm by continuing to act as judges, the Pennsylvania Constitution separately provides for the removal of incapacitated judges, and thus the mandatory retirement provision only serves to force capable judges to retire.

— The electorate unreasonably is deprived of the service of judges they have elected because of an arbitrary age classification, without regard to the judges’ ability to perform their judicial duties.

— Judges over the age of 70 are able to work on “senior” status, performing the same duties as judges under the age of 70, but they are not similarly compensated.  There is no reasonable – or even rational – basis for paying senior judges less money for the same work than judges who have not been forced to retire.   Nor is there any reason to elect and pay for new judges to serve in their place when they are fully competent to perform their judicial duties.

Heim, a nationally known trial lawyer, is a past Chancellor of the Philadelphia Bar Association and past President of the National Conference of Bar Presidents.  He is an elected Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers and the International Academy of Trial Lawyers.

He is a past Chair of the Advisory Committee to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, and he is also past Chair of the Pennsylvania Continuing Legal Education Board.  He served two successive three-year terms on the Federal Advisory Committee on Civil Rules and is currently a member of the Pennsylvania Civil Procedural Rules Committee.  He also serves currently as a member of the ABA Standing Committee on the Federal Judiciary.

A copy of the lawsuit is available online.

NewsClip: 6 Judges Sue Over PA’s Retirement Age Of 70

From Crisci Associates PA Capitol Digest

The Free Student Research Center is closed until January.  Beginning in January, will be open on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays, from 9AM to 3PM. The Free Student Research Center is available for use by attorneys who are current members of the Philadelphia Bar Association’s Criminal Justice Section and who are court-appointed to the case for which they seek research (either state or CJA!). The Free Student Research Center is located in the Jack Myers Memorial Lounge on the Third Floor of the CJC.

You may make a research request in person or via the Criminal Justice Section website by clicking here.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: